How Google Decides Who Ranks #1 (And How You Can Get There Too)

If you've ever asked yourself "Why is my competitor always showing up first on Google?", you're not alone.

Every day, millions of small business owners across the UK are quietly battling for that coveted #1 spot on Google. Whether you're a plumber in Portsmouth, a florist in Fulham, or a café in Cardiff, getting to the top of the search results can make all the difference between being busy and being... well, a bit too quiet.

But here’s the thing. Google isn’t playing favourites. It doesn’t hand out top rankings to whoever shouts the loudest or spends the most on flashy ads (although Google Ads is a separate game altogether). Google ranks websites based on a complex, ever-evolving set of rules called algorithms.

And if you understand what those rules are—and how to play by them—you can dramatically increase your chances of showing up first.

In this guide, we’re breaking it all down for you. No jargon, no fluff. Just a clear explanation of how Google decides who gets that #1 spot... and how your small business can compete for it.

Table of Contents

How Does Google Actually Work?

The Main Factors Google Uses to Rank Websites

Why Local SEO Is Your Secret Weapon

How to Improve Your Chances of Ranking #1

Signs It’s Time to Get SEO Help

FAQ: SEO for UK Small Businesses

How Does Google Actually Work?

Before we get into what gets you to the top, it’s worth understanding what Google is doing behind the scenes.

Imagine Google as a Giant Library

Think of Google as the world’s biggest (and fastest) librarian. Its job is to search through billions of websites and deliver the most relevant results in less than a second.

Google constantly “crawls” websites—like little robot spiders following links from page to page—and adds everything it finds to a massive index. When someone types in a search query (like “best accountant in Birmingham”), Google sifts through that index using a set of rules to decide which website deserves to come out on top.

Those rules? That’s the algorithm.

The Main Factors Google Uses to Rank Websites

Google doesn’t publish its full algorithm (it’s their secret sauce), but SEO experts have studied it for years and Google does drop hints. Here are the most important things we know it looks at:

1. Relevance

Is your website actually about what people are searching for?

If someone Googles “wedding photographer in Leeds”, and your page is about wedding photography, has great examples of your work, and includes words like "wedding", "photographer", and "Leeds", then you’re relevant. That’s a good start.

2. Authority

Google wants to show trustworthy sources. Authority is how it measures that.

One of the biggest signals is backlinks—links from other websites to yours. Think of each link as a vote of confidence. The more high-quality websites linking to yours, the more trustworthy you seem.

3. User Experience

Is your site fast, mobile-friendly, and easy to navigate? If people land on your site and bounce straight off again, that’s a bad sign. Google notices and may lower your rankings.

4. Content Quality

Are you offering genuinely helpful content, or are you just stuffing in keywords? Google’s smart enough to tell the difference. It rewards clear, well-written, useful content that actually answers the questions people are asking.

5. Technical SEO

This includes stuff behind the scenes—how your website is structured, how fast it loads, whether Google can crawl it easily, if your images are optimised, and if your site is secure (i.e. uses HTTPS).

6. Freshness

Google often prefers fresh content. If your website hasn’t been updated in five years, while your competitor is blogging weekly, that might tip the scales in their favour.

Why Local SEO Is Your Secret Weapon

Here’s where it gets really interesting for UK small business owners: local SEO.

Google knows where people are searching from, and it wants to show them businesses that are close to home.

So if someone types in “coffee shop near me”, or even “coffee shop Sheffield”, Google will prioritise businesses that are physically in that area.

Local SEO factors include:

A complete and optimised Google Business Profile

Customer reviews (especially on Google)

Local citations (mentions of your business on directories like Yell, Thomson Local, or Checkatrade)

Location-specific content on your website

A consistent Name, Address, Phone Number (NAP) across the web

Local SEO is the easiest place for small businesses to compete. You’re not trying to outrank Amazon—you’re trying to beat the coffee shop round the corner. And that’s absolutely doable.

How to Improve Your Chances of Ranking #1

Now that you know what Google’s looking for, let’s go through some specific actions you can take to climb the rankings.

1. Start with a Website Health Check

Is your website mobile-friendly? Does it load quickly? Are there broken links? These technical issues can quietly kill your rankings.

Tip: You can use free tools like Google’s PageSpeed Insights and Mobile-Friendly Test to check the basics.

2. Optimise Your Pages for Keywords

This doesn’t mean stuffing keywords everywhere. It means understanding what your potential customers are searching for, and making sure your pages use those words naturally.

For example, if you’re a painter and decorator in Brighton, your homepage should clearly say that.

Add:

A strong heading (H1) like “Professional Painter & Decorator in Brighton”

Useful content describing your services

Internal links to other parts of your site (e.g. gallery, reviews, contact)

3. Set Up and Optimise Your Google Business Profile

This is free, and it’s essential. Make sure:

Your business name, address, and phone number are correct

You’ve chosen the right category (e.g. “Electrician” or “Hairdresser”)

You’ve added photos

You’re collecting reviews (and responding to them)

4. Get Quality Backlinks

This is where an SEO expert can really help, but you can start by:

Asking partners or suppliers to link to your site

Writing guest posts for local blogs

Getting listed in UK business directories

5. Add Regular, Helpful Content

Start a blog. Share tips. Answer common customer questions. Google loves useful content—and so do potential customers.

Example blog ideas:

“5 Signs Your Boiler Needs Replacing (From a Leeds Heating Engineer)”

“How to Choose the Right Wedding Venue in Somerset”

“What Is the Difference Between an MOT and a Service?”

6. Use Local Schema Markup

This is a bit technical, but your web developer or SEO partner can add special code to your site that helps Google understand your business location, opening hours, and more.

Signs It’s Time to Get SEO Help

You can absolutely do a lot of this yourself—but sometimes bringing in an expert makes sense.

You might need SEO help if:

Your traffic has dropped and you don’t know why

You’re not showing up in Google for your own business name

Competitors are outranking you despite offering the same (or worse!) services

You don’t have time to manage content, links, or technical bits

You’re launching a new website and want to get it right from the start

FAQ: SEO for UK Small Businesses

How long does it take to see SEO results?

Typically, 3 to 6 months. SEO is a long-term game, but the results can be long-lasting. The exact time depends on your competition, the quality of your site, and how consistent your SEO work is.

Is SEO worth it for small local businesses?

Yes—especially local SEO. If your customers are mostly nearby, ranking high in local searches (e.g. “barber in Oxford”) can bring in a steady flow of new enquiries.

What’s the difference between SEO and Google Ads?

SEO helps your site appear in the organic results (free listings). Google Ads put you at the top as a paid advert. Ads bring quick results but disappear when you stop paying. SEO takes longer but lasts longer too.

Can I do SEO myself?

Yes—there’s a lot you can do with the right guidance. But for advanced work (technical fixes, link building, in-depth audits), having a professional on your side can save time and boost results.

Getting to #1 on Google might seem like a mystery—but it’s not magic. It’s a mix of relevance, trust, good content, and smart strategy.

As a UK small business owner, you’ve actually got an advantage: you’re local, and you’re niche. That means you can target very specific searches and build trust in your community—two things Google loves.

Whether you decide to take on SEO yourself or bring in some expert help, just remember: getting found online isn’t a luxury anymore. It’s essential.

And the sooner you start, the sooner you’ll be climbing those rankings.

Need help with SEO for your UK business?

Whether you're just getting started or you're tired of being stuck where you are , we offer straightforward, done-for-you SEO services that actually move the needle.

👉 Get in touch today and let’s see what’s holding your site back.- 07816 528421